Home Home

Home

  • Overview of Key Issues in the Pre-Election Period for the June 18, 2022 Ekiti State Governorship Election (Pre-Election Press Statement)

    Overview of Key Issues in the Pre-Election Period for the June 18, 2022 Ekiti State Governorship Election (Pre-Election Press Statement)

    T
    he first of two off cycle governorship elections for 2022 will be conducted by the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC) in Ekiti State, on June 18, 2022. The election is the seventh in the state since the return of the current democratic dispensation in 1999. Following a 2010 Court of Appeal verdict, which removed then Governor Segun Oni, and declared Dr. Kayode Fayemi the rightful winner of the 2007 governorship election, Ekiti became one of several states holding off cycle governorship elections. The June 18, 2022 Ekiti State gubernatorial election is the very first to be conducted under the amended Electoral Act, 2022.

    As voters in Ekiti State head to the polls for tomorrow’s governorship election, the contest is apparently shaping up to be a three horse race involving the ruling party in the state, the All Progressives Congress (APC), the opposition Peoples Democratic Party (PDP) and the Social Democratic Party (SDP), which has clearly emerged as a third force in the election. CDD observes that there are 16 political parties fielding candidates for the election. Only two candidates and seven deputy governorship candidates are women, just as the age range of the candidates indicate low participation of the youth.

    The CDD EAC will be closely observing the electoral process with the objective of collecting data to support evidence-based analysis of key aspects of the Ekiti State governorship election. The CDD EAC will also host a fake news hub for the purpose of tracking and countering fake news and misinformation as it affects the election.

    Pre-Election Observations

    Based on the observation of the CDD EAC in the pre-election period, the following are the key trends, which have underlined the process.

    CDD notes that the June 18, 2022 Ekiti State Governorship election is significant because it will serve as the first dress rehearsal as the INEC prepares for the 2023 general elections. The election will also be the first to be conducted under the Electoral Act, 2022, and the new INEC guidelines and regulations for conduct of elections. CDD EAC further notes that although INEC has made commitments to conduct a credible election in Ekiti State, its success in this regard would depend on its neutrality, professionalism and the level of its understanding and commitment to the new legal framework. The credibility of the process would also depend on how well INEC uses some of its new powers as derived from the extant electoral law, especially the power conferred on the Commission to delay the release of election results, if the Commission needs to take a second look.

    The CDD EAC is concerned about violence, money politics and violations of incumbency powers and the possible effects of these on the credibility of the election. CDD EAC notes that Ekiti State, has recorded several incidents of violence during previous elections. In the build up to the 2022 governorship election, pockets of election-related violence have been recorded in places like Ado Ekiti, Efon Alaiye, Oye, Ido/Osi and Oye Ekiti. Other observable issues, which would shape the credibility of the election include; how well INEC is able to effectively deploy technology, particularly the Bimodal Voter Accreditation System (BVAS), impartial security provisioning, the quality of results management, curtailing the role of money, incumbency and god fatherism in the election. Also critical is the need for stakeholders in the election to proactively track, and counter fake news and misinformation. Already, the pre-election period has witnessed the spread of fake news capable of undermining voter confidence and participation in the process. An example is the fake news which trended recently on a purported Appeal Court decision nullifying the primaries of one of the major political parties and, by extension, its candidate.

    In terms of some of the election risk factor, CDD notes that the ongoing strike by the Academic Staff Union of Universities ( ASUU) has crippled the local economy especially in university towns in Ekiti State. This has created a threat in terms of the availability of idle youth being recruited for activities, which could undermine the credibility of the election. By grounding the local economy, the strike has also created the wrong incentives as voters are more likely to see the election as an opportunity for economic survival, thereby exacerbating the risk of vote buying. This becomes even more relevant when it is considered that Ekiti State introduced the issue of “stomach infrastructure” into the Nigerian political lexicon. CDD has also observed that based on history of past violence in elections in the state, the following Local Government Areas, constitute potential flash points in the election; Ado Ekiti, Efon Alaiye, Ido/Osi, and Oye.

    Signed:

    Professor Adele Jinadu

    Chair, CDD EAC

  • Is Babatunde Fashola Earning 577,000 Naira As A former Lagos State Governor? All We Know

    Is Babatunde Fashola Earning 577,000 Naira As A former Lagos State Governor? All We Know

    On January 20, 2024, Babatunde Fashola, a former governor of Lagos State and the immediate past minister of works and housing, was a guest on Arise TV. The former Lagos State Governor appeared on the Arise network’s exclusive segment tagged: Life After Public Service. 

    While answering questions on the benefit he gets for serving the country in the last 21 years, he said: “the benefit I get is (I think) 577,000 naira monthly pension from Lagos State. That is all I get, and I have come out to deny the billions. 

    Claim: As a former governor of Lagos, Babatunde Fashola earns N577,000 naira monthly pension

    Verification

    Before its eventual ammendment in 2021, the Lagos State Governor and Deputy Governor Pensions Law of 2007 was passed into law by the State House of Assembly to provide several benefits for former governors and deputies who had governed Lagos State. The pension package includes

    • Annual Basic Salary: 100% of the annual basic salaries of the incumbent governor and deputy.
    • Accommodation: One residential house in Lagos and another in FCT for the former governor; one residential house in Lagos for the deputy.
    • Transport. Three cars, two backup cars and one pilot car for the ex-governor every three years; two cars, two backup cars and one pilot car for the deputy every three years.
    • Furniture: 300% of annual basic salary every two years.
    • House maintenance: 10% of annual basic salary.
    • Domestic staff: Cook, steward, gardener and other domestic staff (no limit) who shall be pensionable.
    • Medical: Free medical treatment for ex-governor and deputy and members of their families (not just spouses).
    • Security: Two SSS operatives, one female officer, eight policemen (four each for house and personal security) for the ex-governor, one SSS operative and two policemen (one each for house and personal security) for the deputy.
    • PA: 25% of annual basic salary.
    • Car maintenance: 30% of annual basic salary.
    • Entertainment: 10% of annual basic salary.
    • Utility: 20% of annual basic salary.
    • Drivers: Pensionable (no limit to number of drivers).
    • Severance gratuity: Not specified.

    According to the Revenue Mobilization Allocation and Fiscal Commission (RMAFC) and a report from a reputable media organisation, a State Governor’s basic (monthly) salary is 648,581 naira, while the deputy earns 616,063 naira per month. Their annual salaries amount to 7,782,968 naira and 7,392,753 naira, respectively. 

    Therefore, since Fashola left office as the governor of Lagos State in May 2015, his monthly pension (aside from other emoluments and benefits) was 648,581 naira. 

    However, in August 2021, the Lagos State House of Assembly amended the state Pension Law for former governors, deputies and other political office holders. The highlight of the amendment is the slash of the benefits and emoluments by 50 per cent. Other amendments include the total expungement of the provision of houses in Abuja and Lagos for former governors and the reduction of cars from three to two. 

    With the amended law, the monthly pension of the governor, having been slashed by half, will drop from 648,581 naira to 324,290 naira, five kobo. This is aside from all other benefits (highlighted above). 

    ALL WE KNOW

    The CDD War Room found that the basic monthly pension of a former Lagos State governor as of August 2021 was 648,581 naira (aside from other annual benefits and emoluments). However, when the amendment bill was later passed into law in August 2021, the monthly pension was slashed to 324,290 naira. Based on that amendment (as of January 2024) when Fashola granted the interview, the monthly pension of a former governor of Lagos is expected to be 324,290 naira. 

  • FACT CHECK: Is TETFund recruitment portal currently open as widely circulated online?

    FACT CHECK: Is TETFund recruitment portal currently open as widely circulated online?

    A viral broadcast message circulating on social media claims that the recruitment portal of the Tertiary Education Trust Fund (TETFund) is currently open for 2024/2025. 

    The broadcast message retrieved from WhatsApp reads,  

    “TETFUND RECRUITMENT 2024/2025 PORTAL IS OPEN.

    Click on the link below to start your registration now.

    SALARY RANGES

    For OND Holders (₦35,000-₦50,000).

    For NCE Holders (₦50,000-₦70,000).

    For HND Holders (₦70,000-₦100,000).

    For BS.c Holders (₦100,000-₦180,000).

    APPLY HERE”

    The broadcast message includes a web link purported to be for the agency’s recruitment portal.

    Screenshot of the broadcast message on WhatsApp

    Multiple online blogs have also claimed that the TETFund recruitment portal is open for 2024/2025 as can be seen here and here

    TETFund is a federal government scheme instituted in 2011 to disburse, manage, and monitor education tax to government-owned tertiary institutions in Nigeria. The scheme is under the Federal Ministry of Education.

    Claim: The TETFUND recruitment portal is currently open for 2024/2025

    Verification 

    To verify the authenticity of the viral claim, the CDD War Room checked the web link attached to the broadcast message and found that it was not the official recruitment portal of TETFund.

    The link, archived here, leads to a webpage showing the image of the agency’s headquarters with different sections where applicants are required to fill in their personal details. 

    There are two other pages showing purported comments of successful applicants on Facebook with a supposed congratulatory notification asking applicants to share the link to 5 groups or 15 contacts on WhatsApp. 

    Screenshot of the first page where applicants are required to fill in personal details
    Screenshot of the third page where applicants are asked to share the link to WhatsApp groups

    Furthermore, we checked the official website of TETFund and found a disclaimer notice debunking the viral ongoing recruitment claim.

    Screenshot of the disclaimer notice on the official website of TETFund

    As of the time of filing this report, there is no official announcement of ongoing recruitment exercise by the Tertiary Education Trust Fund.

    Verdict: FALSE

    The CDD War Room can confirm that the weblink in the viral broadcast message with the claim that TETFund recruitment exercise is on, is fake. The agency’s official website shows a disclaimer debunking the claim. As of the time of this report there is no official announcement of ongoing recruitment exercise by TETFund.

  • FACT CHECK: Did the EFCC recently release a list of assets acquired by Betta Edu?

    FACT CHECK: Did the EFCC recently release a list of assets acquired by Betta Edu?

    During the week, a WhatsApp broadcast message surfaced on social media claiming to list assets acquired by suspended Minister of Humanitarian Affairs and Poverty Alleviation, Betta Edu, during her time in office. 

    The message being circulated purportedly originated from the Economic and Financial Crimes Commission (EFCC). 

    This follows mounting controversies surrounding Edu, stemming from an alleged N585 million scandal in her ministry. The latest allegation claims Edu authorized N3.16 million for flight tickets and airport taxis for herself and her team to travel from Abuja to Kogi State, a state, which does not have an airport. CDD War Room investigated the veracity of these claims.

    CDD War Room investigated to authenticate the integrity of the claim.

    Claim 1: Did Betta Edu acquire the above items while in office?

    The CDD War Room rigorously searched the internet for reports from reputable media outlets to verify the claim. Our investigation revealed that the report originated from a website named Afemai Reports. It was observed that the content of the report on this website was identical to the information circulated in the broadcast message, with only the lead paragraph being different.

    Furthermore, the CDD War Room cross-checked multiple news outlets but found that aside from the mentioned website, no other reputable media outlet reported on the claim. The only additional coverage found was in the form of opinion pieces.

    CDD War Room also observed that the items listed had no precise address or name making the claim less verifiable.

    Claim 2: Is there an official EFCC list of assets linked to Betta Edu’s tenure in office?

    Verification

    CDD War Room perused the website and social media handles of the Economic and Financial Crimes Commission (EFCC) to check if there have been any press statements by the commission on the subject matter. CDD War Room found none.

    CDD War Room further contacted the EFCC spokesperson who did not respond to our messages up till the time of filing this report.

    Verdict: No Evidence

    CDD War Room found no evidence to support the claim that a list of assets recovered from Betta Edu, was released to the public by the EFCC. 

  • FACT CHECK: Has Labour Party campaign spokesperson, Kenneth Okonkwo, joined the ruling APC?

    FACT CHECK: Has Labour Party campaign spokesperson, Kenneth Okonkwo, joined the ruling APC?

    A verified X user, Chigozirim Aliyu Emeakayi has claimed in a tweet posted on January 11, 2024 that Kenneth Okonkwo, the spokesperson of the Labour Party’s presidential campaign for the 2023 general elections, has joined the ruling All Progressives Congress (APC).

    The tweet, which has over 62,000 views as of the time of filing this report, reads, “After all the noise, Daniel Bwala and Kenneth Okonkwo have joined the Muslim-Muslim ticket. The worst thing that will happen to a man is to go back to his vomit.”

    This is coming after Daniel Bwala, a former spokesperson for the Peoples Democratic Party (PDP) Presidential Campaign Organisation, paid a visit to Bola Tinubu at the Presidential Villa in Abuja where he expressed his support for the APC-led administration.

    In the last general elections, the APC fielded a Muslim-Muslim presidential ticket which saw Bola Tinubu as its presidential candidate and Kashim Shettima as the vice presidential candidate.

    CLAIM: Kenneth Okonkwo has joined the ruling All Progressives Congress (APC)

    Verification

    To verify the above claim, the CDD War Room assessed the interview recently granted by Okonkwo on National Television.

    In the interview aired on January 11, 2024, Okonwo was asked to react to Doyin Okupe’s resignation and Bwala’s declaration of support for Bola Tinubu, among other political issues regarding the Labour Party.

    While he stated that Bwala’s visit to the president was not out of place, he, however, condemned him for pledging support for the APC-led government.

    Okonkwo said, “It is just that I have not had enough evidence to convict myself. There is nothing wrong in seeing the president because you don’t say no to a president.

    “However, there is something psychophantically wrong when you make a 360 degree on the principles you say you hold dear. What are the things that have changed?

    “The president is the Commander-In-Chief of the Armed Forces and he has the right to command me to come and see him and I would not have a choice but I will have a choice to what I will say.

    He added, “I will have a choice to my demeanour once I have finished seeing him because what he cannot command is what I will say but if he says I must see him, then I have to see him.”

    When asked if he was a member of the Labour Party, Okonkwo responded, “Yes, I am a member of the Labour Party.”

    Verdict: FALSE

    The claim that Kennet Okonkwo has joined the APC is false. As of the time of filing this report, CDD War Room can confirm that he is still a member of the Labour Party and he has not made any statement indicating readiness to join the APC government or the ruling party.  

  • FACT CHECK: Is Shell Leaving Nigeria?

    FACT CHECK: Is Shell Leaving Nigeria?

    On January 16, 2023, the news went viral across social and traditional media that Shell is leaving Nigeria. On X (formerly Twitter), there are several accounts that the multinational oil company is closing down operations in Nigeria due to the harsh economic condition, oil bukering / theft, pipeline vandalism and other issues that are affecting their operations in Nigeria. 

    The CDD War Room therefore checks the veracity of the claim.

    Claim: Is Shell leaving Nigeria? 

    Verification:

    In 1936, The Royal Dutch/Shell Group founded Shell D’Arcy, the first Shell company in Nigeria. The company was granted exploration license in November 1938 and by April 1956, the name was changed to Shell-BP Petroleum Development Company of Nigeria Limited, poupularly called Shell SPDC Nigeria. 

    Shell PLC Nigeria has over the years moved from onshore oil exploration company, to have several other subsidiaries. They are: 

    I. THE SHELL PETROLEUM DEVELOPMENT COMPANY OF NIGERIA (SPDC)

    This subsidiary of Shell Nigeria is the pioneer and leader of the petroleum industry in Nigeria. SPDC is the operator of the NNPC/SPDC/Total Energies/NAOC Joint Venture and supplies onshore and shallow water oil and gas to domestic and export market from its operations in the Niger Delta.

    II. SHELL NIGERIA EXPLORATION AND PRODUCTION COMPANY (SNEPCO)

    This subsidiary of Shell Nigeria pioneered deep-water oil and gas production from the Bonga field in the Gulf of Guinea where depths reach more than 1,000 metres. Asides oil production, SNEPCO has helped create the first generation of Nigerian oil and gas engineers with deep water experience and stimulated the growth of support industries.

    III. SHELL NIGERIA GAS (SNG)

    Shell Nigeria Gas Ltd is a fully owned Shell company incorporated in 1998 for the downstream distribution of gas to industries in Nigeria. SNG currently operates a growing world class gas transmission and distribution network of over 138km in Nigeria. It operates several distribution systems including Agbara-Ota in Ogun state, the Aba Cluster in Abia State, and the Port Harcourt Cluster in Rivers State. 

    IV. SHELL ENERGY NIGERIA

    Shell Energy Nigeria is growing Shell‘s presence as a natural gas marketing and sales business in Nigeria to support the ‘Decade of Gas‘, an initiative by the Government of Nigeria to deploy gas as a fuel for economic development. This subsidiary is to support expanding the role of gas in power generation, local industry and to help provide new energy solutions across Nigeria

    Asides these major subsidiaries, Shell Global has interest and investment across other sectors of the Nigerian economy. They include: 

    1. DAYSTAR POWER 

    Shell Overseas International B.V. (SOI B.V.), a wholly owned subsidiary of Shell plc (Shell), acquired Daystar Power Group (Daystar). The acquisition is to provide integrated solar power solutions, and bring reliable energy to businesses in West Africa, helping customers reduce power costs and pollution.

    1.  NIGERIA LNG LIMITED (NLNG)

    The first NLNG project in Nigeria is a joint venture between Shell, NLNG, Total and ENI. Shell holds a 25.6% share, NNPC holds 49%, Total holds 15% while ENI holds 10.4%. NLNG accounts for approximately 7% of the world’s total liquefied and natural gas supply. 

    It is therefore important to know that of all these Shell subsidiaries and investments in Nigeria, it is only the Shell Petroleum Development Company (SPDC) that is closing operation in Nigeria; leaving other subsidiaries and investments in the country.

    In addition, Shell has agreed to sell its Nigerian onshore oil and gas assets (SPDC) for a total of $2.4 billion to the Renaissance Oil. The Renaissance Oil is a consortium which includes ND Western, Aradel Energy, First E&P, Waltersmith and Petrolin.

    According to the announcement, Shell will sell the Shell Petroleum Development Company of Nigeria Limited (SPDC) for a consideration of $1.3 billion,while the buyers will make an additional payment of up to $1.1 billion relating to prior receivables at completion.

    Verdict: MISLEADING

    The claim that Shell is leaving Nigeria is misleading. The oil and gas multinational is only selling the Shell Petroleum Development Company of Nigeria Limited (SPDC), one of its subsidiaries to a consortium led by Renaissance Oil. Its other subsidiaries such as SNEPCO, SNG and investments in Daystar and NLNG are still in operation in Nigeria. 

  • FACT CHECK: Did the Kano State Governorship Election Tribunal uphold the victory of Abba Yusuf? 

    FACT CHECK: Did the Kano State Governorship Election Tribunal uphold the victory of  Abba Yusuf? 

    The Supreme Court recently delivered judgement in pending governorship election petition cases on January 12, 2024. On the Arise TV Good Morning Show, Reuben Abati, while analysing the litigious nature of the 2023 general election, noted that the cases of Ebonyi and Bauchi were straightforward due to consistent decisions by the tribunal and appellate courts. However, Abati noted the complexity in states like Kano, Plateau, and Zamfara. It was at this point that he claimed that the Governorship Election Petition Tribunal in Kano delivered judgement in favour of Abba Kabir Yusuf of the New Nigeria Peoples Party (NNPP). The show host went on to assert that the decision of the Tribunal was overturned by the Court of Appeal in favour of Yusuf Gawuna of the All Progressives Congress (APC).

    In his words, “But Kano presents a different case; Plateau presents a different case, Zamfara also presents a different case. Let me just run through them very quickly. In the case of Kano, this is NNPP vs. APC or vice versa. This is Governor Yusuf vs. Yusuf Gawuna, and the key point here has to do with, one, the membership of the political party: can another political party inquire into the membership of another political party? The second is, Can a candidate be punished for the omissions of INEC, because in this case, the tribunal had originally ruled in favour of Govenor Abba Yusuf of Kano, but when the matter went to the appellate court at the instance of Gawuna and the APC, the appellate court found differently…”

    Verification 

    CDD War Room found that on Wednesday, September 20, 2023, the Kano State governorship election tribunal delivered a judgement that sacked Abba Kabir Yusuf of the NNPP as the governor of the state. The Tribunal subsequently declared APC’s Nasir Gawuna the winner of the March 18 governorship election. The three-man panel, which delivered its verdict via Zoom, ordered the withdrawal of the certificate of return from the NNPP candidate, and have it presented to the APC flag bearer. CDD War Room recalls that the initial result released by INEC after the March 2023 governorship election in Kano State showed Yusuf polling 1,019,602 votes to defeat his closest challenger, APC’s Gawuna who polled 890,705 votes, declaring Yusuf the winner with a margin of 128,897 votes.

    However, contrary to INEC’s count, the tribunal’s ruling invalidated 165,663 votes belonging to the NNPP. This deduction was applied to the initially declared 1,019,602 votes. In November 2023, the Court of Appeal sacked the governor, thereby upholding the decision of the election tribunal. In addition to upholding the decision of the Tribunal, the appellate court went further to disqualify the governor; it cited a violation of Section 177(c) of the constitution, which provides that a person must be a member of a political party and sponsored by that party to qualify for election as governor.

    Dissatisfied by both the decisions of the election petition tribunal and the Court of Appeal, Abba Yusuf headed to the Supreme Court. The Supreme Court, in its judgement delivered on January 12, 2024, quashed the verdicts of the tribunal and the appellate court. It consequently held that Yusuf of the NNPP was the duly elected governor of Kano State.  

    Verdict: INACCURATE

    The Kano State Governorship Election Petition Tribunal did not uphold the election of Abba Kabir Yusuf, as claimed on the Morning Show. Instead, the Tribunal sacked the Kano State Governor and declared the APC candidate as the lawfully elected governor. The Appeal Court also concurred with the verdict of the Tribunal. However, those judicial outcomes at the tribunal and appellate court levels were struck down at the Supreme Court, thereby affirming the electoral victory of Abba Kabir Yusuf as Governor of Kano State.

  • FACT CHECK: Did Philip Shuaibu Say He Felt Betrayed By Obaseki For Not Backing His Gubernatorial Bid?

    FACT CHECK: Did Philip Shuaibu Say He Felt Betrayed By Obaseki For Not Backing His Gubernatorial Bid?

    On January 10, 2024, the news went viral on X (formerly Twitter) that Philip Shuaibu, the deputy governor of Edo state and one of the gubernatorial aspirants under the umbrella of the Peoples Democratic Party (PDP) called Godwin Obaseki, his principal, a betrayal. 

    According to another tweet, Shuaibu expressed his sense of betrayal by his principal, Godwin Obaseki, for not backing his candidature in the upcoming 2024 governorship election. He was reported to have called his principal a betrayal on Arise News. 

    Context: 

    The CDD War Room found that Godwin Obaseki, the incumbent governor and his deputy, Philip Shuaibu, have recently been at loggerheads. In August 2023, the governor sacked Shuaibu’s media aides and relocated his office to the former Edo State Public Procurement Office at Osadebey Avenue in Benin City. 

    In September, the deputy governor, Philip Shuaibu, was reported to have sought forgiveness from the governor, Godwin Obaseki, for any unintentional mistakes he may have committed.

    At his investiture as the Grand Patron of the Catholic Men Organisation of Nigeria of the Catholic Archdioceses of Benin, Shuaibu also said, “I use this medium to appeal to Mr. governor that if there is any mistake I have made or if there anything that I have done that I don’t know of, he should please forgive me so that we can develop our state together.” 

    It is believed that this entire feud is hinged on the fact that Philip Shuaibu declared interest to run for the governorship of Edo State on the platform of the Peoples Democratic Party (PDP). 

    Claim: Philip Shuaibu calls Obaseki a betrayal for not backing his gubernatorial bid

    Verification: 

    On January 10, 2024, Philip Shuaibu appeared on the Arise News Morning Show, where he answered questions on the upcoming Edo governorship election and the political atmosphere in the state. While answering a question asked by Ayo Mairo-Ese on whether the governor endorsing another candidate would be considered an act of betrayal by the deputy governor. Shuaibu said, “ I feel betrayed by the governor. I feel very betrayed and not just been betrayed. He alluded to a Bible verse and said, “The heart of man is desperately wicked, so when I see what the governor is doing and relate it to what the verse of the Bible said, it is now making meaning to me.” 

    Verdict: True

    The CDD War Room found an interview granted by Philip Shuaibu, the deputy governor of Edo state and a gubernatorial aspirant contesting for the PDP ticket. In the interview, he said he felt betrayed by the governor for not supporting his gubernatorial bid. 

  • FACT SHIELD: Key Lessons From Repeated Disinformation Targeting Former South African Leader, Mbeki

    FACT SHIELD: Key Lessons From Repeated Disinformation Targeting Former South African Leader, Mbeki

    On January 3, 2024, as individuals and families on the African continent were sharing “happy new year” messages, the disinformation machine went into overdrive. The target of the disinformation was former South African President Thabo Mbeki. The false claim that flooded social media was that Mbeki, who succeeded anti-apartheid icon Nelson Mandela, had died. This claim initially surfaced on TikTok, where a user shared it. The now-deleted post was shared over a thousand times across various platforms, with the claim that the “former South African president dies at 74.” Within a few hours, the news was swiftly disseminated through the South African and international media spaces. Several senior journalists from reputable media houses also found themselves joining the frenzy, sharing the claim with followers who, vouching for the credibility of such media professionals, also pushed the offensive content across cyberspace.

    CDD War Room recalls that Mbeki, renowned for his pro-democracy credentials, served as the deputy president to freedom fighter Nelson Mandela. He secured the popular vote in the South African presidential election in 1999, becoming the second post-apartheid leader of the “rainbow nation” of South Africa. His presidency was characterised by macroeconomic reforms and sustained economic growth. Thabo delivered the legendary “I am an African speech,” showcasing his political oratory akin to that of Martin Luther King Jr. 

    Shortly after the fake news of his demise circulated, an alternative report emerged. The Thabo Mbeki Foundation released a statement that debunked the death rumours; the South African icon, the foundation stressed, was alive and well. It therefore urged the general public to exercise “caution when engaging with online information at a time when misinformation can easily spread rapidly.”

    The CDD War Room also found that the January 3 fake news blitz concerning the elder statesman was not the first; in 2016, Ghana’s Broadcasting Corporation erroneously reported his death after lifting information from a now-defunct satirical website. In 2021, similar rumours regarding his death from COVID-19 complications surfaced, prompting the Thabo Foundation to debunk the claims.

    The toll of constantly witnessing erroneous reports of one’s passing globally is undoubtedly distressing. On January 10, 2024, seven days after the initial reports, the 81-year-old Thabo was seen at the funeral service of Peter Magubane.

    Responding to health inquiries, he said, “I am very well. Thank you. That story originated from somebody in Ghana in 2016, and they keep popping it up every year. I don’t know what the intention is; we have told the Ghanaian government that they must attend to it. It is a silly story, but as you can see, I am alive and well, and a happy new year to everyone.”

    Identifying the menace of information disorder across social media and how users can mitigate the spread

    What the fake news on Mbeki shows is the fact that not everything that circulates on social media at a frenzied pace is true or authentic. Misinformation, disinformation, and malinformation are all consequences of a disorder in the information system—an anomaly in the ecosystem. “False information packaged as the truth” is a consistent feature of all three. Disinformation, however, involves a deliberate intention to deceive. Experts have identified social media as a primary driver of disinformation. But there are ways to avoid getting caught in the embarrassing act of spreading fake news, wittingly or unwittingly.

    How then can social media users avoid falling prey to the allure of fake news?

    1. Verify the news piece that catches your attention before resharing it on social media. Wait, and ask: Has this been reshared by multiple credible news agencies? Even if shared by a credible source, how many credible sources are sharing it? While the lure of breaking news may be exciting, it is important to wait and substantiate that it has been reported across more than one credible news agency. It’s worth noting that even news agencies are susceptible to errors stemming from impatience or eagerness to break the news. An example is the incident involving the Ghana News Corporation in 2016, which first reported the untrue story of Mbeki’s demise. They admitted, in an apology statement released afterward, that they had not thoroughly read the content of the piece from which they extracted false news.
    2. Double-check the source of the news. Some particular social media handles are known to stoke the fire of mischief; you can identify this from their engagement and the pattern of news content they share. Be wary and, like the Thabo Foundation said, “cautious” of whatever information emanates from said source. 
    3. Be critical when engaging with information. When you come across news, ask the fundamental question, “Is this true?” and seek answers before disseminating it.
    4. Be conscious of bias. Some news reports may align with personal desires, whether subconscious or conscious. Self-awareness is essential when engaging with news, including differentiating between opinions and facts.
  • FACT CHECK: Is The “I DO NOT AUTHORIZE” Viral Message On WhatsApp Authentic?

    FACT CHECK: Is The “I DO NOT AUTHORIZE” Viral Message On WhatsApp Authentic?

    A message on WhatsApp has gone viral, alleging that the social messaging app now has a “new rule that allows you to use your whatsapp.” The alarming part of the broadcast message is that “everything you’ve posted can be posted starting today, even deleted messages.” That is, the WhatsApp (system) admin can access posted and deleted messages. 

    Another part of the broadcast message reads that WhatsApp will cost 0.01 euro per message unless you send this message to 10 people. ‘’When you do, the light will turn blue otherwise, WhatsApp will activate billing.”

    Verification

    The CDD War Room found that the “I do not authorize” broadcast message went viral in February 2021, shortly after WhatsApp notified Its users of an update in its terms of service and privacy policy. According to the circular, the update was expected to take effect in February 2021. The announcement read, “By tapping Agree, you accept the new terms and privacy policy, which take effect on 8 February 2021. After this date, you’ll need to accept these updates to continue using WhatsApp.”

    The announcement generated uproar and mixed reactions, compelling WhatsApp to shift the date of effect from February 8 to May 21, 2021. 

    We therefore found that the purveyors of this “I do not authorize” message took advantage of the new update on WhatsApp’s terms of service and privacy policy to spread the message.

    The CDD War Room found some other discrepancies in the purported message. 

    The first discrepancy is the spelling of WhatsApp as “Whatsap” in the first paragraph. Instead of a double P, the broadcast message used a single P. 

    The second discrepancy is the inconsistency in the deadline date. The first sentence reads “Remember, the new Whatsap rule that allows you to use your photos begins tomorrow!” while the second sentence goes thus “Remember that the deadline is today!!!” The first sentence says it begins tomorrow, while the second sentence says today. Moreso, such policies are expected to carry a specific date when such updates will take effect. 

    Finally, the paragraph that says “WhatsApp will cost 0.01 euro per message is false as the social messaging app does not charge per message.

    The CDD War Room can therefore establish that these discrepancies are enough to categorize the “I do not authorize” broadcast message as fake and circulated to mislead the public. 

    Verdict: FALSE

    The CDD War Room found that the “I do not authorize” broadcast message did not emanate from WhatsApp. We found several discrepancies in the viral message that show the broadcast message is fake and circulated to mislead the public. 

  • FACT SHIELD: All To Know About The February 3rd Re-Run & Bye-Election Across Nigeria

    FACT SHIELD: All To Know About The February 3rd Re-Run & Bye-Election Across Nigeria

    The Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC) recently announced that it will conduct nine bye-elections and 35 re-run elections on February 3, 2024. The elections will be held in Lagos, Ondo, Kebbi, Taraba, Yobe, Benue, Kaduna, Ebonyi and Borno states. 

    Since the announcement, there have been reactions from several stakeholders as to why INEC is moving to conduct re-run and bye-elections barely a year after the 2023 general election. 

    Why INEC conducts bye-elections? 

    A bye-election becomes necessary when an elected official resigns, dies, or is recalled from office. This means when an elected position becomes (formally) vacant, the electoral umpire (INEC) is expected to conduct a bye-election. 

    A re-run is conducted where the election does not meet the constitutional standard or there is a pronouncement by a court of competent jurisdiction. Should an aggrieved candidate approach the court, the court may upturn the decision of the electoral umpire and order a fresh election in the affected polling units. 

    It is on this premise that INEC is conducting nine bye-elections and 35 re-run elections across nine states of the federation. However, the states have peculiar reasons for the conduct of these elections. 

    Bye-elections due to resignation by elected officials

    INEC will conduct bye-elections in two senatorial districts of Ebonyi South and Yobe East due to the appointment of Dave Umahi and Ibrahim Geidam as members of the federal executive council. The duo were senators until Bola Tinubu, the president of Nigeria, appointed Umahi as minister of works and Geidam as minister of police affairs. They had to resign as senators and join the executive arm of government, and their seats were declared vacant by the Senate President and communicated to INEC. 

    The gale of resignation was recorded at the House of Representatives, necessitating the conduct of bye-elections to fill the vacant seats. 

    In Lagos state, Femi Gbajabiamila, who was representing Surulere I federal constituency , was appointed as the Chief of Staff to the president. Therefore, he resigned his legislative position to work as the president’s top aide. 

    Olubunmi Tunji-Ojo from Ondo state, who currently serves as the minister of interior, resigned his membership as a legislator. He was representing the Akoko North-east/ Akoko North-west federal constituency. Hence, the seat was declared vacant, and the re-run is expected to provide the next person to fill the vacant position. 

    In Kebbi state, Tanko Sununu, representing Yauri/ Shanga/ Ngaski federal constituency at the House of Representatives, resigned to join the federal executive council. He was appointed as the minister of state for education by Bola Tinubu. Hence, the need for INEC to conduct a bye-election to fill the vacant legislative seat of Yauri/ Shanga/ Ngaski federal constituency. 

    Bye-election due to the death of an elected official

    In Taraba state, a bye-election will be conducted due to the death of Ismaila Maihanchi, who was elected as the honourable member to represent the Jalingo/ Yorro/ Zing federal constituency. He died after being declared the duly elected candidate but before the inauguration of the 10th National Assembly. 

    Re-run elections due to court judgement

    After the 2023 general election, some aggrieved parties approached the tribunal to upturn the results declared by INEC and requested for re-run elections. In some instances, elections were marred by violence and substantiated malpractices, necessitating the cancellation of votes and the call for a re-run in the affected polling units. 

    Hence, the a need for a re-run in three state constituencies of Benue, Borno and Kaduna. Other affected state constituencies include Guma in Benue State, with one LGA, 116 PUs and 63,529 registered voters; Chibok in Borno State, comprising one LGA, 118 PUs and 55,498 registered voters; and Chikun in Kaduna State, involving 543 PUs and 334,071 registered voters.

    INEC has therefore announced February 3, 2024 as the date for all the re-run and bye-elections across the affected states of the country.